Skip to main content

Dinner Menu

Our chefs prepare every dish with care to ensure our customers enjoy the best dining experience possible. Classy casual, everyday style food made from fresh ingredients from local farms and fisherman makes our menu reminiscent of "wicked" good New England cooking.

APPETIZERS

  • Steamed Middleneck Clams
    15.99

    One pound of the finest clams sautéed in a garlic butter sauce with bits of linguica sausage, onions and celery

  • Steamers
    1 lb | MP 3lb | MP

    Fresh soft shell Longneck clams steamed to perfection, served with drawn butter and lemon.

  • Peel & Eat Gulf Shrimp
    14.99

    A half pound of shrimp steamed along with the Captain’s Special Seasoning served chilled or hot with cocktail sauce.

  • Kettle of Mussels
    13.99

    One pound of fresh mussels sautéed in a garlic and wine sauce or marinara sauce.

  • Chicken Tenders
    12.99

    All white chicken, breaded & deep-fried, served with our homemade BBQ sauce or honey mustard or marinara sauce.

  • Crab Cakes
    19.99

    Our own recipe of lump blue crab cakes served with our remoulade sauce.

  • Clam Strips
    13.99

    Sweet tender meat of sea clams from New England, hand battered and deep-fried to perfection.

  • Shrimp Cocktail
    14.99

    Five colossal chilled Gulf shrimp served with a lemon wedge and cocktail sauce

  • Fried Fiery Shrimp
    14.99

    Baked with our spicy roasted pepper cheese sauce and topped with Parmesan. Served with garlic toast.

  • Broiled Fiery Scallops
    18.99

    Baked with our spicy roasted red pepper cheese sauce and topped with Parmesan. Served with garlic toast.

  • Fried Calamari
    15.99

    Tender tentacles and rings breaded and fried to perfection. Served with Marinara sauce.

SOUPS

  • Lobster Bisque
    Cup | 7.99 Bowl | 10.99

    Taste of Sarasota Award Winner!
    Prepared in lobster broth and then pureed with lobster meat, cream, and sherry.

    Add Lobster Chunks | 5.00

  • New England Clam Chowdah
    Cup | 6.99 Bowl | 9.99

    Our family recipe from Cape Cod. Contains bacon.

  • Portuguese Soup
    Cup | 6.99 Bowl | 8.99

    A hearty soup prepared with fresh kale, potatoes, assorted beans, onions, linguica, and Chourice sausage, blended with our soup broth and other spices.

SALADS

  • Garlic Ranch House Salad
    12.99

    Crispy greens, spring mix, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, Parmesan and olives tossed with our homemade garlic ranch dressing.

  • Mediterranean Feta Salad
    12.99

    Crispy romaine lettuce tossed with lots of Feta cheese, red onions, ripe tomatoes, olives, and fresh Parmesan cheese blended with a light vinaigrette dressing.

  • Caesar Salad
    11.99

    Romaine mixed with our special dressing, topped with freshly shaved Parmesan cheese and fresh garlic croutons.

  • Watermelon Salad
    13.99

    Crisp spring mix, goat cheese, watermelon, sliced almonds, and seasonal berries tossed in our berry vinaigrette dressing.

  • Add To Any Salad

    Shrimp | 7.00
    Grilled Chicken | 6.50
    1/4 Lb. Lobster Meat | 15.00
    8 oz. Grilled Fish (Salmon, or Mahi) | 8.50
    Clam Strips | 6.00

SEAFOOD NET

Served with two sides.

  • Clam Strips
    16.99

    Sweet tender meat of sea clams from New England, hand battered and deep fried to perfection.

  • Alaskan King Crab
    MP

    1 pound of sweet crab legs steamed and served with hot drawn butter.

  • Baked Stuffed Haddock
    24.99

    North Atlantic haddock stuffed with our seafood stuffing, sherry wine and topped with fresh Parmesean cheese.

  • Sea Scallops
    28.99

    Simple and sweet New England sea scallops lightly battered and fried, or broiled in garlic herbed butter and topped with seasoned bread crumbs.

  • Ipswich Clams
    28.99

    New England’s best-bellied clams, lightly battered then deep fried to perfection.

  • Shrimp
    18.99

    Ten large shrimp fried, grilled or blackened.

  • Baked Stuffed Shrimp
    24.99

    Large shrimp stuffed with our special crab stuffing then broiled in a garlic lemon butter sauce

  • Shore Dinner
    28.99

    A combination of shrimp, scallops and fish served fried or broiled in a garlic herbed butter with seasoned bread crumbs, and served with fried clam strips.

FROM THE LOBSTER POT

Served with two sides.

  • Baked Stuffed Lobster Dutchess
    MP

    Award Winner!
    A specialty of the house! A family recipe that will tantalize your taste buds.

  • Lazy Dutchess
    MP

    New England lobster meat prepared with our famous seafood stuffing, splashed with Sherry wine, topped with Parmesan cheese and baked to perfection.

  • Whole Maine Lobster
    MP

    1⁄4 Lbs. Boiled or Broiled and topped with bread crumbs.

  • Maine Lobster Tail Dinner
    MP

    7oz. Maine lobster tail steamed or fried to perfection and served with hot drawn butter.

    1 Tail
    2 Tails

  • Lobster Roll Dinner
    28.99

    Chilled Maine lobster tossed in mayonnaise and served on top of lettuce in a toasted New England roll.

CAPTAIN'S PASTA AND RICE DINNERS

  • Baked Lobster Mac & Cheese
    33.99

    Fresh lobster and pasta in a 3 cheese sauce topped with bread crumbs. Served with garlic toast.

  • Salmon Rockefeller
    22.99

    Baked salmon filled with creamy spinach, bacon, Parmesan stuffing with pernod, topped with hollandaise sauce, served over rice with fresh vegetables. 

  • Jambalaya

    A sauteed spicy tomato sauce with smoked sausage over rice served with garlic toast. *Seafood includes shrimp, scallops, fish, mussels & clams.

    Chicken | 18.59
    Shrimp | 20.99
    Seafood* | 28.99

  • Seafood Portugal
    39.99

    A favorite of the Pot! An assortment of fresh mussels, clams, steamers, lobster and shrimp sautéed with linguica, celery, and onions in a lemon garlic butter sauce, then served over pasta with garlic toast.

  • Salmon Monte Carlo
    20.99

    Lightly blackened Salmon topped with our fresh white wine garlic cream sauce, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, and mushrooms, then served over pasta with Parmesan cheese.

  • Lobster Ravioli
    MP

    Lobster stuffed ravioli tossed in a tomato basil cream sauce served with a char-grilled Maine lobster tail and garlic toast.

  • Pasta Fiery Dishes

    Sautéed in a spicy roasted red pepper cheese sauce topped with Parmesan served over a bed of pasta with garlic toast.

    Chicken | 18.59
    Shrimp | 19.99
    Lobster | MP
  • Alfredo Dishes

    Our homemade Parmesan and Romano Alfredo sauce served over a bed of pasta with garlic toast.


    Chicken | 18.59
    Shrimp | 19.99
    Lobster | MP

  • Florentine Dishes

    Fresh chopped spinach, garlic, bacon, pernod, and aged Parmesan tossed with pasta in a white cream sauce.

    Chicken | 18.59
    Shrimp | 19.99
    Lobster | MP

STEAKS AND CHOPS

  • New York Strip
    36.99

    12 oz. choice center cut char grilled to perfection, served with garlic toast

  • Filet Mignon
    39.99

    6 oz. choice center cut tenderloin grilled to perfection and served with garlic toast

  • Pork Chop
    22.99

    Center-cut bone-in pork chop marinated then char-grilled to perfection and served over apple chutney.

FISH DINNERS

We strive to offer you the best selection of fresh fish we can obtain, when available. Served fried, grilled, blackened or broiled with your choice of two sides and corn bread.

  • Mahi
    20.59
  • Haddock
    20.59
  • Cod
    18.99
  • Salmon
    20.99
  • Catch of the Day
    MP

SIDE DISHES

  • Mash Potatoes
  • Seasoned Rice
  • Cole Slaw
  • French Fries
  • Vegetable of the Day
  • Baked Beans
  • Chunky Apple Sauce

BEVERAGES

  • Soft Drinks
    3.79
  • Iced Tea
    3.79
  • Bottled Water
    3.99
  • Sparkling Water
    3.99
  • Large Coffee
    3.10
  • Hot Tea
    3.10

Warning: Raw and under cooked items such as meats, fish, eggs, and shellfish can pose a health risk to especially young children, pregnant women, older adults and those with compromised immune systems.